Well your original statement came off as an "anti-all motor" statement, but this one justifies what you meant better.
Personally, I love boosted Hondas, I've had my share of boosted cars, and I love boost. But at this point, I'm going after a reliable car, that I can jump in on a whim, and drive across the country, without having to worry about a return line busting off, or a charge pipe blowing off, etc.
But back to my original point... Show me a
boosted 230whp Type-R that can run 11.98. While yes, for the money, you could have built a 450whp engine that could have run the same times... But why do that, when you can do it just on the motor?
That's my view point... I'm an all motor guy, people don't get us, haha.
... Uhhh, no dude, it wouldn't be a "stoplight car" at all. How would you lose top end with a tight geared transmission? Type-Rs are factory road course cars, you have PLENTY of top end with them. Trust me man, I drive one every single day.
Most Type-R owners put in an even tighter final drive (Typically a JDM 4.785FD, or an ATS/SRR/M-Factory 4.928FD or 5.077FD... Stock USDM Type-R and '96-'97 JDM Type-R is 4.400FD), people that track their cars every weekend. Tight gearing's a good thing, it's not like you're going to top out at 120mph with a stock Type-R transmission.
A Type-R transmission would be PERFECT for your build. Stock LSD, tight gearing, great gear ratios. A wider geared transmission absolutely kills an all motor setup. A buddy of mine swapped a Type-R engine (Purchased legit from a reputable Honda-Tech seller) into his '98 LS, and left the LS transmission in. We went from second on the highway, and by top of fourth, I had 3 cars on him.
Yes, gearing makes that big of a different.
As for price. I see Type-R transmissions sell on a daily basis for $1,000-$1,200 in awesome shape. I sold one of mine for $800 with a second gear grind. The guy who bought it, fixed it with a spare syncro he had. It's well worth the money, if you try to build a B16 or a GSR transmission to match it's performance, you're going to be spending just as much as a stock Type-R transmission would run you.
I laughed when I read B16 on your list... If you think Type-R is too tight, B16 shouldn't be on your list either.
How about a stock Type-R clutch for $300? Type-R clutches do awesome with all motor setups.
Myself personally, I'm using ACT Street-Lite/ACT HD pressure plate/ACT unsprung 6-puck. But that's because my all motor build I'm going with right now,
should generate around 210-215whp, and I'll be spraying a 50 shot on top of that. So I'll need a bit more grabbing power when I'm running 22" slicks, launching at 7,500RPM, and spraying off the line.
But for 240-250whp, a stock Type-R clutch will be awesome. If you decide you need a bit more gripping/holding power, just go with a Competiton Stage-II.
You've got a LOT of good advice in this thread. I'd recommend you listen to it.
