Does this piss you off?

[Frög]

if you saw the same video, with a old nasty Pig getting tossed, more than half of you would laugh.. wierd since pigs are smarter than dogs.. This video is very sad, but seriously..

I'm going with fake as well.
'
The dog looked already dead. The yelping sounded too fake and not from the dog.

They did it just to make a sick joke, and I'm sure they knew everyone would think it was real. For those smart enough to know it's fake, it isn't that big of a deal.

imo it didn't sound fake, my pup sounded exactly like that.. regardless i doubt anyone that has gone through puberty cannot imitate that noise.. so this knocks out all option except post editing..

i had my pup at about that age.. could barely open its eyes, he was abandoned and the only reason we found him was because of his yepping.. didn't even sound like a dog, but sounded just like the one on the vid..

your right, soldiers would'nt do that.. im sure he was dead.. just like the soldier in iraq a year or so ago who killed a whole family and raped the daughter that was 16 I think?

How can you say, for those "smart enough to know its fake"? this isn't "will the plane take off on a treadmill" which is proven, factual and science.. im sorry but this is probably the most ignorant and dumb comment in this thread.. Do you think the Marines, PETA etc... would do such an investigation if it was so obvious?

http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2008/...n3907067.shtml

With the quality of the video, its impossible for you or I to say.. I think its real, but I could be wrong, qnd so could the ppl who think it is fake.. i think im right, but im not going to affirm anything untill its fact.. thats the smart thing to do..


ANYWAY, this guy does not deserve death, and nobody would kill him because that would only put them in the same boat.. What he did was beyong wrong, but get real, its a fu.cking dog!! Do you know how many innocent people get killed weekly in iraq by soldiers? Do you know how many dogs get runned over and killed daily in the U.S? we are freaking out about this one dog when there are alot bigger issues to worry about..

And yes, i support the death penalty, but not for killing a dog..

It's ok for Vick to abuse dogs for years and fight them to death, but a couple of bored US soldiers who fight for our freedom are immediately scrutinized for tossing a dead puppy that they found.

UPDATE: Vick is in jail.. so i guess that makes it...... NOT ok.. and no one is sure wether the pup was dead or alive..

and if it was dead, its a pretty tasteless joke.. i might have to lol..

[Humphrizzle]

this makes me sick. I would very much enjoy kicking the **** out of this *******. Why would you ever throw a puppy, or any harmless animal off of a cliff? It wouldn;t be funny if it was fake or real.

This guy is a waste of matter and belongs next to the puppy.

F uck all the fa ggots in the video because they could have stopped it from happening. But laughed about it and said "thats mean..."

Aassholes

[Frög]

QD is a conspiracy theorist.
There is a spoon.
There are no stuffed dogs in the Middle East.

Reasons why its not fake:

Why would a US soldier be carrying around a stuffed puppy?
Where would he get a stuffed puppy?
Where if it were already dead, why are its eyes still open, and no wound marks?
You can't video edit it cause the quality of the camera is so bad....

hope your kidding!

[Thighs]

this makes me sick. I would very much enjoy kicking the **** out of this *******. Why would you ever throw a puppy, or any harmless animal off of a cliff? It wouldn;t be funny if it was fake or real.

This guy is a waste of matter and belongs next to the puppy.

F uck all the fa ggots in the video because they could have stopped it from happening. But laughed about it and said "thats mean..."

Aassholes

dude is JUSt a dog. chill out. if it was him doing something mean to another person you would be laughing.

[collins]

jesse, i wouldnt

[BKgen®]

jesse, i wouldnt

x2

[ubers2k]

QD is a conspiracy theorist.
There is a spoon.
There are no stuffed dogs in the Middle East.

Reasons why its not fake:

Why would a US soldier be carrying around a stuffed puppy?
Where would he get a stuffed puppy?
Where if it were already dead, why are its eyes still open, and no wound marks?
You can't video edit it cause the quality of the camera is so bad....

Where would he get a stuffed puppy? Hmmm.... well, since families do send stuff to their friends and loved ones who are IN the military, it's very possible that one could have been sent to him.

Where if it were already dead, why are its eyes still open, and no wound marks? When a dog dies, the eyes DON'T close. I know, I held my dog as she was put down. Besides the fact that she wasn't breathing, she looked to be alive. And as for the "no wound marks" part, regardless of whether it was dead or not (IF it was alive), we don't know HOW it died.

Oh, and about the video editing part... did you not see Cloverfield? Granted that was a major production, but anything is possible with film.

On another note, regardless of whether this was real or a joke, it's inappropriate. It shouldn't have happened and it definitely shouldn't have been recorded. Just my

[Thighs]

yes you would. and chances are you have before.

[Frög]

QD is a conspiracy theorist.
There is a spoon.
There are no stuffed dogs in the Middle East.

i missed the funny part..

Reasons why its not fake:

should say "dumbest/weakest reasons why its not fake"

Why would a US soldier be carrying around a stuffed puppy? Where would he get a stuffed puppy?

to make a video and post it online? What if he found the stuffed puppy in a house they raided.. The options are endless! all very unprobable offcourse but thats not the point. please tell me you have never written a argumentative essay!!

suitable argument would be that it doesn't look like a stuffed puppy because (state reasons here, maybe it didn't seem stiff, and that most stuffed animals are stiff etc..)

Where if it were already dead, why are its eyes still open, and no wound marks?

1st: Eyes often stay open after death, this is common on most mammals..
2nd: Do all dead mammals have wounds? ever heard of disease, starvation, or internal bleeding?

You can't video edit it cause the quality of the camera is so bad....

wow it only gets better.. its the opposite buddy.. the worst the quality, the easier it is to edit.. also, it is common that the quality decreases after editing it...

[BKgen®]

yes you would. and chances are you have before.

Hey miss Cleo, where the fuck do you get off telling us what we would/wouldn't feel when watching a video?

[Alan®]

It's ok for Vick to abuse dogs for years and fight them to death, but a couple of bored US soldiers who fight for our freedom are immediately scrutinized for tossing a dead puppy that they found.

No it's not ok for either of them to do what they did but as these guys are soldiers in a forein land they are supposed to represent us in a positive light. Not killing puppies cause they are bored

[TheGodfather]

Jeesh, imagine if they had video cameras of all the crazy things soldiers in Nam did. That would make some peoples stomachs turn.

[EJ25RUN]

If i was that guy standing next to him, i honestly would have shanked him in his face.

[IP37]

what the ****? you guys are overreacting. i mean, yeah thats pretty ****ty but nobody would really push him off a cliff or shoot him or blah blah blah. its just a dog. people do mean **** to each other all day but when somebody does something mean to another species everyone freaks out. why?

i sure would push his ass off the cliff

[Thighs]

i sure would push his ass off the cliff

i doubt that...

[OneSlow5pt0]

i hope he is discharged and would like charges to be filed

[ubers2k]

i doubt that...

That seems to be all you have been doing. How the hell would you know what we would or wouldn't do given the current situation? Are you any of us? Do you know what goes through each and every one of our heads? No, you don't. I have an idea... shut the **** up with the remarks on whether we will/will not do something. I sure as **** wouldn't have allowed that to happen had I been there.

[wantboost]

That seems to be all you have been doing. How the hell would you know what we would or wouldn't do given the current situation? Are you any of us? Do you know what goes through each and every one of our heads? No, you don't. I have an idea... shut the **** up with the remarks on whether we will/will not do something. I sure as **** wouldn't have allowed that to happen had I been there.

you would kill someone for throwing a dog.....

then go to jail for killing a human......

sounds smart to me.....

[SL65AMG]

It may be real. But I kept watching the puppy for signs of life(not necessarily a dead puppy, but a stuffed one). I know if you pick up a cat by the scruff of the neck, it generally doesn't move about, as if in some sort of paralysis. But not sure with a dog. Also, I was trying to discern if the "yelping" was that of another person out of camera. It's really hard to tell. The dog also quit "yelping" a bit before impact. I'm no expert at this by any means, but I'm pretty confident that there would at least be some sort of noise from the animal upon striking the ground. Later, QD.

the vid definitely looks real as does the puppy.... and it looked like it went pretty far out, hence the lack of yelps and thuds from the puppy....


that **** is messed up

[hondachik]

im not talking about arguing. but if you saw a video of a guy getting hit in the head from behind you would most likely laugh. im not talking about when people do dumb stuff on purpose. but just like this dog couldnt avoid it, you wouldnt know if the person behind you was gonna hit you REALLY hard in the head.

just think about it.

just my personal situation...I wouldn't laugh because that's just mean. I have a heart. Besides that fact, my uncle just got hit in the back of the head on Sunday morning by a soldier at a club he's security for. A punka$$ soldier that ran. So now, I highly doubt I laugh considering the fact he's supposedly bleeding inside his head.

[jew_boy]

wtf that dude needs his ass beat

that pisses me off just watching that

[hondachik]

1st: "it's a puppy" not "he's a puppy"
2nd: WTF are you talking about? it seems like your in your own world, trying to explain something to 1st graders.. You try to explain your argument but make absolutely ZERO sense.. And the few things one can get out of this pre-school post is common sense!!! seriously, FUC.KING DUH!!!!

comment wasn't directed towards you. the person who needed to respond already did. thank you.

[Frög]

Jeesh, imagine if they had video cameras of all the crazy things soldiers in Nam did. That would make some peoples stomachs turn.

How bout nagasaki and hiroshima in WWII. The further you look back the worst it gets, so its irrelevant..

Everyday there are a infinte things worst than this stupid dog happening in iraq.. Yes i hope this guy gets in trouble if he did what I believe he did.. BUT if anyone of you would actualy kill a human because he killed a ****ing RAT, your worst than him!!!! Not bashing on the people that said that. Most of us can understand that it is only said because it is the worst existing punishment, thus expressing their excruciating anger..

Seriously though, have any of you seen videos of slaughter houses? Unless your a vegetarian STFU!!! I love animals and I hate when people mistreat them, but i think PETA and alot of americans today take it way too far.. look at other countries, like china, where it is a delicacy to eat monkey brain from a LIVE baby monkey.. probably illegal, but not really inforced..


FOR GOD SAKES I FUCKING DISSECTED A KITTEN LAST SEMESTER!!!

How bout we forget about this and get to the real crimes..

http://www.fbi.gov/ucr/cius2006/about/crime_clock.html

[ubers2k]

you would kill someone for throwing a dog.....

then go to jail for killing a human......

sounds smart to me.....

Wow. Reading comprehension isn't your friend, is it? Where in any of my posts did I say I would kill the guy? I said that if I was there it wouldn't have happened, granted I could stop it. Does that mean that I would put a bullet in his head? No. I'd **** him up, sure, but I wouldn't kill the guy.

Please, before you decide to act/sound smart, read and then RE-read what you're quoting before you run your mouth about it. Thanks.

[wantboost]

Read the post that you quoted (including who he quoted), and you are attempting to lecture me on reading comprehension? You are hilarious.

[wantboost]

just to refresh your memory, read and re-read as you so put it. all this is under the assumption that the guy would die if his"ass" got pushed off the cliff

i sure would push his ass off the cliff

then...

i doubt that...

after that.....

That seems to be all you have been doing. How the hell would you know what we would or wouldn't do given the current situation? Are you any of us? Do you know what goes through each and every one of our heads? No, you don't. I have an idea... shut the **** up with the remarks on whether we will/will not do something. I sure as **** wouldn't have allowed that to happen had I been there.

.....

you would kill someone for throwing a dog.....

then go to jail for killing a human......

sounds smart to me.....

Wow. Reading comprehension isn't your friend, is it? Where in any of my posts did I say I would kill the guy? I said that if I was there it wouldn't have happened, granted I could stop it. Does that mean that I would put a bullet in his head? No. I'd **** him up, sure, but I wouldn't kill the guy.

Please, before you decide to act/sound smart, read and then RE-read what you're quoting before you run your mouth about it. Thanks.

you never mentioned anything about you just beating his ass in your reply to jesse..... i guess you want me to be a psychic and comprehend something that is not there? Ok buddy....

all this is attempt to make it easier for you to comprehend, hope it helps.

[ubers2k]

just to refresh your memory, read and re-read as you so put it. all this is under the assumption that the guy would die if his"ass" got pushed off the cliff


then...

after that.....

.....



you never mentioned anything about you just beating his ass in your reply to jesse..... i guess you want me to be a psychic and comprehend something that is not there? Ok buddy....

all this is attempt to make it easier for you to comprehend, hope it helps.

Not once did I agree with what was said, and I never said I would kill the guy. All I did was make a remark in regards to the "I doubt that" post. Where did I say that I agreed that the guy responsible should be killed? Please, point that out and I will see your point. Until then, you fail.

[wantboost]

you obviously missed the point...

with that i am not wasting any more time on you.

good day.

[ubers2k]

you fail to realize that the point I made was that jesse is doubting that any of us, given that we were there, wouldn't do a damn thing. I told him to stfu about that because he doesn't know whether we would or wouldn't do anything, and then you came in here saying that killing the guy was, sarcastically put of course, "smart." Not once did I agree that killing the guy was a "smart" thing to do, therefore your "point" is not valid.

I saw the point you were trying to make, but you apparently didn't understand what I was saying, therefore your point towards me was actually pointless.