this is like the age old question on here. half say boost half say na. u will never get ia to come to an agreement on this at all or atleast enough to get the result your looking for. i say budget, usage, and power goals will be your deciding factors. i know u listed budget and usage. im supercharged and i love it but i also have a v8 truck. ill different from a honda it supercharger is always there for u till its maxed out.