I'm sorry, but without specific details on what was going on when those wheels broke, there is no way to determine if it was a mfg. fault or something else. Simple as that. I have seen some of the highest brand wheels break under track fatigue. But it also depens on what you mean by "track". If you're looking for some light wheels to take to the drag strip/auto-x... i dont think Rotas are going to give you any problems at all. Under the stresses of hard road coarse driving, then i would go with a forged wheel. I have seen the Team Dynamics wheels severely crack on spec-miata cars from the heat of the brakes.. not from getting hit. I have also seen BBS wheels sheer the center clean off the barrel of the wheel from heavy use. Honestly, its all relative to what you're doing.

This past weekend i was at the BMW DE at Road Atlanta and saw several cars running Rotas with no problems. I used Rotas from drifting for awhile with no problems, and im using Enkeis for both DD and drifting with no problems. I have seen the lips on several SportMax wheel randomly break though....