I feel like...

[MachNU]

[QUOTE=Ruiner]I am not in the wrong! If he tells me to get out of my car, I can assume that he is in the process to carjack me which is a felony. Wouldn't you agree? Yes or no? Read part C!



No fighting in court at all. He had a deadly weapon! He was committing a felony and was risking my pysical safety! It's very clear cut.QUOTE]

First part your ass would be in jail if that happened. If you had a gun and he had no weapon and you shot him THEN YOU USED EXCESSIVE FORCE. Courts would eat you alive becuase you had chance for great bodily harm, and you had no way to be in fear for your life.

Second i just said that would still be one that would go to court and have to fight a small bit, not like major trying to send your ass to jail fight but it would be one that had to be cleared over in court! Like situation 2!


Also this is kinda along the lines of what you are saying!

"A man may defend himself and even commit a homicide for the prevention of any forcible and atrocious crime, which if completed would amount to a felony; and of course under the like circumstances, mayhem, wounding and battery would be excusable at common law. A man may repel force by force in defence of his person, property or habitation, against any one who manifests, intends, attempts, or endeavors, by violence or surprise, to commit a forcible felony, such as murder, rape, robbery, arson, burglary and the like. In these cases he is not required to retreat, but he may resist and even pursue his adversary, until he has secured himself from all danger."

[Ruiner]

First part your ass would be in jail if that happened. If you had a gun and he had no weapon and you shot him THEN YOU USED EXCESSIVE FORCE. Courts would eat you alive becuase you had chance for great bodily harm, and you had no way to be in fear for your life.

You DO NOT have to be in fear for you life! Read the law! It can be used to prevent a felony! I can shoot someone to PREVENT a felony such as a carjacking! You can carjack without a weapon! It's called a strongarmed robbery!

Second i just said that would still be one that would go to court and have to fight a small bit, not like major trying to send your ass to jail fight but it would be one that had to be cleared over in court! Like situation 2!


Also this is kinda along the lines of what you are saying!

"A man may defend himself and even commit a homicide for the prevention of any forcible and atrocious crime, which if completed would amount to a felony; and of course under the like circumstances, mayhem, wounding and battery would be excusable at common law. A man may repel force by force in defence of his person, property or habitation, against any one who manifests, intends, attempts, or endeavors, by violence or surprise, to commit a forcible felony, such as murder, rape, robbery, arson, burglary and the like. In these cases he is not required to retreat, but he may resist and even pursue his adversary, until he has secured himself from all danger."

Stop, all states have different laws! Where did you get this quote from? This DOES NOT summarize the GA law!

[MachNU]

Stop, all states have different laws! Where did you get this quote from? This DOES NOT summarize the GA law!

Its not for just any state it just explains a legal term. So it may differ at some poitns pending ont he state but it just gives s general idea to what the term stands for.

[Ruiner]

Its not for just any state it just explains a legal term. So it may differ at some poitns pending ont he state but it just gives s general idea to what the term stands for.

Umm, you CANNOT go on "general" ideas like that. Laws are VERY specific. You have to satisfy certain criteria. Read the GA law and read the actual law, not some summary.

[MachNU]

Umm, you CANNOT go on "general" ideas like that. Laws are VERY specific. You have to satisfy certain criteria. Read the GA law and read the actual law, not some summary.

already doing that... i figured you would say this when i said that, so i am alreayd at the page!

[Ruiner]

already doing that... i figured you would say this when i said that, so i am alreayd at the page!

http://www.legis.state.ga.us/cgi-bin...l?code=16-3-21

[MachNU]

http://www.legis.state.ga.us/cgi-bin...l?code=16-3-21

already know about that page..... bu ti am looking at 16-3-24/.1/.2 right know!