Wow last time i was in this thread, It had only 9 pages i think, dam.
Wow last time i was in this thread, It had only 9 pages i think, dam.
GOT VTEC?
lot to respond to, let me get to work...... Spoiler alert... Nelson is still a moron.
Understood. Variables indeed.![]()
Last edited by Doppelgänger; 12-19-2012 at 08:46 AM.
02' Miata
I dont think i would ever choose a KA over an SR20, for reasons ive already stated. SR20s are not garbage, they are proven well designed platforms and easy to swap.
Sometimes you get people who want to be different and go against the norm, before they realize that the norm is the norm for a reason.
Enterprise Data Resources- Ecommerce Project Manager
-www.usedbarcode.net
forgot to comment on the gearing post last night. I doubt i will express my argument in it's entirety as im pressed for time and walking out the door soon.....
but in terms of drag racing or acceleration, the argument you present is correct in theory.... but it doesnt factor in mechanical limitations. One thing that makes the SR20 great is it's long smooth climb through the RPM. As the car begins to move, the stress transferred through the body lightens and during the course of acceleration the SR20 climbs in power steadily. If you launched on a 1000hp diesel engine that was geared to do 200mph, you would either A break or B have a transmission/gearbox heavy duty enough that the weight and resistance of it would hinder your speed.
The worlds fastest diesel makes 1800lbs of torque to run nearly the exact same time as the SR20 outlaw street car. The diesel is a rail. I would imagine that power plant in a real car chassis would probably spit the axles into the 7th row of the stands or do nothing but spin. Same reason that semis have so many gears.
For road racing application, those cars spend the entire race in motion. They dont deal with the initial drivetrain shock like a drag car does. As you stated previously..... if we were talking about the best engine for a different application.... IE road racing, hill climbing.. nascar or whatever..... that would completely change the argument. For the purpose of simplicity, and since it's what i know.... i'm limiting my argument to drag racing/power/acceleration
I can't really see what you're getting at there Sin. Please elaborate, specifically on the mechanical limits you mentionedBut I will make the following post to show you what I understand of gearing, power delivery, and what I tihnk you were getting to.
What I can say is engines with broad torque curves (diesel-powered drag cars & big V8 drag cars) can use 2 and 3 speed transmissions (Powerglide, for example) because they have the available torque to turn long gears. Not to mention these types of transmissions don't really multiply torque like a transmission with 5+ gears. I see the Mazworx/Micks Motorworks "S15" uses a G-force 5speed clutchless transmission. To me, that translates into the SR20 they're using simply doesn't have the available torque to run a long gear set with a minimal amount of gears. They need more gears to keep the engine in it's peak power range for maximum acceleration. Nothing wrong with that, it's just what is needed for the application. If you had a 1800ft/lb diesel engine and have it geared to go 200mph, you don't need the lower gears for torque amplification to get moving (this is the reason 18-wheels have 17 gears- not because they always need it, but to super amplify the torque to move heavy loads). If anything, in theory it would be easier to make a 18-wheeler spin tires because of how much the short gears amplify torque, but they run out of RPMs too quickly. An unloaded 18-wheeler cab can accelerate just fine with skipping/splitting gears. I'm sure QD can elaborate on just what/how many gears can be skipped when driving a cab. Point of that is, without the [heavy] load, the usable range of RPM, is longer because the amount of torque required to accelerate is less. With a heavy load, the usable RPM range is reduced because more peak torque is required and shortening (splitting and hi/low range) the gears keeps the engine in the usable RPM range. This is a direct relationship to the SR20 powered car using/needing 5 gears because it doesn't have a broad enough RPM range when making peak power to use long gears.
Going on that you said "if you were to put [a diesel engine] in a real car chassis, it would probably spit axles", is kinda void IMHO because you wouldn't use X engine on Y driveline or Y enigne on X driveline- X engine with X driveline, Y engine with Y driveline. I understand what you're getting at with shock load though- sending 1000+ft/lbs through the driveline at launch and using torque to accelerate vs 400ft/lbs at launch and using RPM generated horsepower to accelerate as available torque decreases (your statement about "the stress transferred through the body lightens and during the course of acceleration"). But the shockload might not be as bad as you're thinking because the gears aren't really multiplying the torque output through the transmission- the powerplant makes enough torque to accelerate. Shorter gears/multiple gears are used for amplifying/multiply power output because the powerplant itself does not make enough to do all the work on its own to start accelerating. I don't think there is much to get into when talking about driveline loss and required equipment to handle power either because it works both ways....if you're making big power, you need the parts that can handle it. But the less moving parts you have on the driveline, the less loss there is.
Like I said, I don't mind a civil discussion at all, nor do I mind being corrected. Heck, while typing that up, I skimmed over a few builds of drag cars, watched a video to completely understand how a semi-truck's transmission works (I knew the basics, but seeing the high range and low range being used with the splits was helpful) and saw pictures of really cool engine builds and turbo setups.
Last edited by Doppelgänger; 12-20-2012 at 11:40 AM.
02' Miata
I got as far as HP per PSI in this thread, first post, line I don't know and I'm too lazy to go back... This might be an ignorant question but is HP per PSI a real worthy metric for anybody on this site or for a daily?
IMHO doing the whole comparing PSI thing is also very hard. It comes down to CFM more importantly. Unless you are comparing psi on the same setup, it really cannot be compared. PSI =\= flow. Sin's analogy of blowing through a coffee straw and a regular straw is a perfect example.
It's not a race but you don't want to follow behind when In a tandem. I've seen a ka running pretty much the same setup as a sr and putting it to shame simply because it has more low end torq (well more trq period). The sr is awesome simply because its cheap has forged internals and can with stand a good amount of boost/beating. Giving if you just add a good set of h beam rods and cp pistons to the mix for the ka you have now eliminated the weak point of the ka. Put the same turbo on both and set the psi to let's say 10. On the drift course you will notice a big difference the ka will 9/10 put 1-2 cars. Mainly that's all depends on the skill level of the drivers but I've seen this at Kms where a sr was having a very hard time keeping up with the ka. Only down fall to the ka is the reliability and the fact none of these kids dare to open it up and actual build the motor. So far I like the sr hasn't given me any issues yet just telling you what I've noticed. I've never really seen a built ka vs built sr with similar builds go at it so its harder to judge which of the two is better. Stock for stock though the sr wins hands down. I have seen some pretty quick n/a ka's make some of those guys at Kms with sr's look bad though lol.
<3 Catnipples
I simply cant fathom comparing engines based on a novelty "race". I understand what you're saying.... but i put no value on the results. You're intentionally making your car go around the track in a slow and inefficient manner... then comparing the ability of the engine to do this.
Anyone else find it funny that nelson was bringing up sinfix's word games, but he kept repeating the same thing by twisting the words around and using synonyms of words he had already used until someone finally agreed with his argument?
Yes new people go slow but people with actual skill arnt going slow at all. 40-50 in a slide is not all that easy. I don't consider it a sport but its fun. I don't consider time attack a motor sport so why shouldn't drifting be any different on comparison. One you're trying to maintain the car on one particular line on the track trying to get the best time where is drifting is based more on style and speed. Being able to go fast and carry momentum into a full lock slide.
Since you don't like drifting I wouldn't think you would get the comparison. Just because one doesn't like baseball doesn't mean it's not a hard sport to play. I'm just stating what I've seen and what I've seen is a closely built ka will out do the sr simply because it doesn't have the low trq needed to carry the momentum through the turns so we have to rely on its ability to rev really high. So every transition I'm having to match rev and keep my rev really high in between clutch kicks. If the ka is built your not having to worry about that since the low end trq is like a crutch giving I don't have to rev so high all the time. You can deff tell they created the ka for trucks in mind. It's very responsive on the low end.
<3 Catnipples
Just to give an update on this matter as more details have been unveiled. It would appear that the highly anticipated world beater of a rb26 s14 turned out to be a bucket.
The white sr s13 is now broken down. Apparently said car that was "sniffing my tail pipes" @ 19psi was actually tuned for 14 psi and it popped on the boost. All the talk about how poor my HP numbers were for the amount of work done.....
well ladies and gentleman.....
This is why. There's a big difference between a well built sr20 that yawns at anything the small turbo can possibly throw at it and a non built sr20 that is running at it's breaking point. This 14 psi car popped @ 19 psi, my sr20 stayed @ 25psi for years. I'd drive it across country @ 25psi.
Another thing Nelson doesnt seem to understand when he flaps his pole polisher about his KA.
None of this matters to me too much as i am retired from the "240sx game", however.... i do still get tingly inside when i get to say i told you so.
Sorry to burst your bubble sinfix but the car didn't pop at all I'm replacing the head gasket only for safe measures for next season sorry if I made it seem as if it was broken down. I didn't have to take it apart I wanted to. I'm OCD and like shit done the right way but the s14 was a bucket.
<3 Catnipples
Aiming more at the false advertising. You talked these cars up when they were in large part a mystery to you, as you are now revealing. Nelson does the same, but 10x worse..... Nelson's car had a dyno sheet and a track time before it fired over. From experience, you cant race cars with receipts.
if the car didnt break, and these are just things you're discovering, thats a different story, but its still false advertisement.
I'm OCD to an existent. How can I cut a hole to be perfect if its already cut out smart one? I know your just trying to start shit so it's cool. If anything I can mold rubber around the "jagged edges" not that anyone would notice it since my inter cooling piping will be coming through there and the intake pipe off the turbo with mad will be blocking the view of these horrible jagged edges.
Your trying to hard to get sin fix to talk shit about my work. Childish.
<3 Catnipples
Lol, give it up. I told you exactly how to do it. I know what I'm talking about, and it won't just be me that thinks your car looks like complete shit.
Sorry for trying to help, but thanks for giving me a good laugh at your poor taste.
and lol again @ "OCD" and "OCD to an extent"
'92 C2500 6.5 Turbo Diesel | '96 240sx
Ok dude. My car isn't for everyone's liking. I'm busting my ass are you? So please save me your bull shit. The car will look and be a lot better then it was so thAts fine by me that your stating my car looks like shit before you even see the finished product. Only negative thing you can come up with was the cut out was bad (which I didn't do). Pathetic, please save your poor argument for someone who cares. I'm not trying to impress Anyone but simply show casing i can build a car better then cb7tuner.
Before
After
So what your saying is my car looks like shit based of a photo of a car in this condition lololololol oh shit guys I have jagged edges in my engine bay!!!!! Wow you must be the holly grail of building cars. Excuse me while I bow down and kiss your feet.
<3 Catnipples
lol. Don't be mad at me because your car looks like shit.
Spray paint. Spray paint on half ass cut off brackets. Spray paint on half ass cut holes. Spray paint on rubber. Spray paint on wires. Spray paint on bolts. Spray paint on the latch. Spray paint on heater core. Spray paint on a/c lines. Spray paint on brake lines. Spray paint on half of the hinges. Spray paint on the wiper assembly. Did I mention it's spray painted? And let me guess, if I saw it in person, I'd see a lot of obvious places that don't even cover the previous color?
I didn't make your car look like shit.
If you wouldn't go around repping "OCD" like it's a gift from God, I wouldn't think so lowly of your pile. You're not OCD and this isn't a build.
'92 C2500 6.5 Turbo Diesel | '96 240sx
Lol wow guy you try to hard.
You are making this website shit FYI.
I'm not a professional therefore you can't expect professional body and paint work. Jokes on you though.... Brake lines will be steal braided. Wiper assembly isn't even there all plastic pieces are in the garage. Wires will be pulled and re done and re wrapped. Did I mention this wasn't the finished product ? I guess you have a hard time reading let me type slower for you.... T h I s I s n o t t h e f I n I s h e d p r o d u c t.
My car is a pile ok thanks for the criticism guy. Now my gf would like to use my dick so would you be so kind to give it back or are you not done riding it ?
<3 Catnipples
Giving y'all's so called intelligence level I would expect more. Catnip you suck at talking shit. You can't even admit that what I did looks 20x better then it did before which is what I was trying to do. This car will be at drift events every month so chances are this engine bay will e crushed. So why the fuck would I care if I sprayed over the heater core lines or bolts you stupid fuck. You have to be the dumbest mother fucker to try and talk shit to me. When I said OCD I ment for the mechanical side of the build as in the wiring and head gasket and all re other crap that was bad. The paint i did as part of down time waiting on parts. For my first time ever in my life painting a engine bay I did a pretty damn good job. No runs; cleared and i tapped off what will still be in the engine bay. I didn't care to pull the brake lines nor did I feel like doing the wiring at that present moment.
I'm done trying to talk to people like you. Your the best we know. Now fuck off pussy.
<3 Catnipples
I'd be mad as hell, too, if I had to drive that, lol.
'92 C2500 6.5 Turbo Diesel | '96 240sx
Wow you're that dumb lolol
Drifting is a style of driving much like dragging. I'm not emo nor am I hipster. Your moronic comments are over whelming. You hate on drifting because you can't do it or your older and don't understand it. There is a lot of technique and engineering that goes into drifting. As far as my car is concerned its on a high plat form in drifting. what if I said auto x was for sissy ass fags ? Your argument lacks substance your insults are that of a 3 year old. What is it you do ? I bet it involves a parking lot huh....
<3 Catnipples