Hahha, I think the basic idea was (correct me if I'm wrong) there was a guy who made a thread complaining that he gets blown off by women because he's average looking in preference for guys who are good looking but treat them like shit. Bunch of girls chimed in claiming that it wasn't true, and they go for personality rather than looks, etc, etc. Evadethishonda made this thread in response to the girls, pointing out instances where he's seen them be superficial, in a nutshell. Please note, this is just a cliffnotes version, not my opinion.
And Ruiner, would you rather have an average looking woman who was smart, funny, great in bed, etc - or an amazing looking women who was the opposite (dumb, clueless, dead fish in the sack, etc)?

I think that's the general question being posed, hehe.