I had that happen at a buddies apt. I was fuking pissed. The kid tried to deny it but when we all confronted him and he saw there was no way he didn't do it, he ended up giving me $200 in cash.

G/L with getting your situation resolved....hopefully they will treat it like a hit and run...get his tag documented...and take it from there. Look at it this way...NEW PAINT JOB!!!! WOOT!!