I liked Heath's portrayal better (don't get me wrong, I'm also a big fan of Nicholson's), but like everybody else is saying, the movies portrayed them in two different lights. So, you really can't compare.

Quote Originally Posted by d-ninja
Also Jack Nicholson had a series of movies to establish his character, whereas Heath only had a single movie.
Que? If I'm understanding what you mean correctly, then you're wrong.