Your age hurts you no matter what. All insurance companies will screw you blind so expect nothing less. Geico has always been insanely expensive for Georgia drivers. Even though they are located in Macon, GA, their employees can't afford to buy from them. Whoever you go with, shop them everytime your renewal comes up. I promise you there isn't a insurance out there that has any loyalty to their customers so why should you have any loyalty to them. Every insurance company has different opinions on which cars they prefer to insure. Over the years I've had better than average pricing from Cincinnati, Liberty Mutual, and on occasion State Farm. Good luck with your search.