That's pretty tough. Obviously the cars are very different from each other, so it would all depend on his needs. I would probably go with the Vette personally, I drive a first gen mr2 so practicality really isn't an issue for me. If I was buying a DD and had a fun car, possibly the Evo. If the cars were more similar it would make for a better debate, but since we have no idea what this guy wants or needs out of the car it's not like I can help decide for him.