YES
NO
I have not read past the first few posts, but anyways if this hasnt been said, what if two students start fighting, student 1 comes at student 2 with chair attempting to hit him with it, student 2 pulls out his peice and shoots student 1. now would that be considered stand your ground law? if it would be, how often do you think it would happen? Anyone ever seen the southpark episode, where the guys are hunting and cant shoot the animals unless they are "coming right for them."
it's going to be one messy case...unless student 1 comes out of nowhere and tries to attack student 2...Originally Posted by dohc4.6sc
What do you mean by a messy case? As in the police determining who was at fault? I'm talking about both students are arguing, student 1 (who is acroos the room) grabs a chair and runs at student 2. Would that be considered up under the"stand you ground" law? If so, then i think when students get into disputes they could shoot one another and get out trough a loophole. I.E. he had a pencil in his hand, and said he would stab me in the throat.
Last edited by dohc4.6sc; 04-28-2008 at 10:02 PM.
messy as in student 2 is pretty much fuxored unless he has all kinds of witnesses saying he was attacked for NO REASON, if he had any part in the fight then no, the stand your ground law will not hold up for you.
in either case like jconner just said, the chances of this even happening like the way you envision is slim to none...
i love your sig picture!!!!!!! the people that cannot comprehend why criminals shoot up schools should simply look at that picture
the two students that are involved in this "fight" are immature enough to start this "fight." This would not be two students that are atleast 21 years of age and have taken the time to get a lisence to carry. The kids that get in a fight and throw chairs at each other are the students that pull out their ILLEGAL "piece" as the criminals call it and shoot each other.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote