This is going to turn into the same thing as your dirty wheel picture thread a while back. Just because someone doesn't like what you do or how you do it doesn't mean you have to get defensive and go after them like you did when you replied to his comment. Im not taking anyones side...but you obviously want to see what other people think or you wouldnt have posted the link. Why talk about his photog skills when this is a thread you created about your own work? He simply stated his opinion...and no matter how you take it...its still his opinion. If you are truly "doing it for yourself" then read what he has to say and move on...dont reply talking down on his work when thats not even the subject. Hell if I were you I would appreciate stuff like that and try to improve my work.