You know not who among your children and your parents are nearest to you in benefit. This is the law of Allah. Indeed Allah is wise, all knowing.

Obviously, the extent of help and co-operation which a person receives from his parents, children and other close relatives cannot, normally, be paralleled by any other association. Undoubtedly, the world has always considered the kins of a deceased as the rightful beneficiaries of the wealth that he leaves behind. But certain issues, in this regard, have always remained unresolved. For instance, who among the relatives is nearest with respect to the benefits he holds for the deceased, and how should the shares of inheritance be calculated on this basis. It is not that the human endeavour in this regard has fallen prey to lack of application, rather it is due to certain inherrent limitations of the human mind which have made this task beyond its reach. Love, hatred, prejudice and other emotions have made it very difficult for the human intellect to come to grips with this challenge. Consequently, the wise and the all knowing has Himself guided mankind in this regard to relieve them from the disorders which have originated and can originate on this account.

Thus, the basic principle on which the shares of the various relatives of the deceased have been assigned is the benefit that accrues or can accrue from these relations to the deceased.

After this clarification, let us look at some of the objections raised by Mr. Katz in this regard. Mr. Katz states:

Imagine the situation that a man dies and leaves no direct heirs but only a brother and a sister. His sister might be a widow with children, without support from others, but she has to feed her children. The brother might be a rich business man and bachalor who has nobody to take care of but himself. Nevertheless, the brother will get 2/3 and the sister will get 1/3 of the estate.

As stated earlier, the basic principle in the assignment of shares is not the "need" of the particular inheritor but the benefit that has accrued or can accrue from this relation to the person in question (the deceased). Furthermore, it must also be kept in mind that the assignment of these shares is not the only means of supporting a 'needy sister'. A person has all the authority and right to give away as much of his assets as he desires, during his life, to any of his relatives who are in need. The shares mentioned in the verses under consideration are shares in the inheritance of a person. Such inheritance, if it is to be regulated in any way, cannot be regulated by keeping only exceptional situations in view. There can be a number of ways of dealing with such exceptional situations, if the person really wants to do so, while following the law in letter and spirit. (Most of the examples and situations given by Mr. Katz may be considered in the light of this paragraph).

Mr. Katz writes:

The male does get double the female no matter what their respective financial situation is and how many people depend on them. He might voluntarily give money to the needy relative. But the inheritance law does not say so, and he does not have to.

I am surprised to read what Mr. Katz has written here. Obviously, it is not for an inheritance law to suggest to a sharer in the inheritance to give up his or her share for some other sharer. The purpose of an inheritance law is only to assign shares to various relations of a deceased in a generally acceptable and just manner. I am sure Mr. Katz will not negate my statement that the Qur'an has generally prompted its believers to spend for the well being of their relatives. Not only that, the Qur'an persuades the Muslims to spend for the general well being of others, even in times of difficulty and financial stress.

It is very unfortunate that while considering an idea different from our own, we are more interested in pointing out what, according to our own (sometimes erroneous) thinking, 'should have been', rather than find out and understand what really 'is'.

I hope that Mr. Katz and all those who read this article will notify me of anything that is incorrect or is not based on the proper understanding of the Qur'an or the Arabic language.

© Copyright 1998. All Rights Reserved with the Author


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

[1] Mr. Katz's article can be seen on the internet at:
http://www.answering-islam.org/Quran/Contra/i001.html

[2] The explanation of the law of inhritance of the Qur'an is based on the researh of my teacher, Javed Ahmad Ghamidi.

[3] Regarding the share of the parents, the Qur'an says:

...if the deceased has children, the parents shall inherit a sixth each, and if he has no children and the parents are his only heirs then his mother shall receive a third, and if he has brothers and sisters then the mother's share is the same one-sixth.

If we look at this part of the verse closely, we shall see that in case the deceased has any children or, in the absence of children, has any brothers and/or sisters, the parents are to receive a fixed share (one-sixth each) of the total inheritance. Thus, we may conclude that in the presence of either children or brothers and/or sisters of the deceased, the parents get a fixed share in the total inheritance.

From the last line of the referred part of this verse, which says that the share of the deceased's mother is returned to the original share (i.e., the share stipulated for the mother in case the deceased had any children -- one-sixth), one may easily derive that if a person dies childless but has any brothers and/or sisters:

the share of the deceased's father will also be one-sixth, which is the original share of the deceased's father (i.e., the share stipulated for the father in case the deceased had any children -- one-sixth); and
the brothers and/or sisters of the deceased shall take the same position, with regards to inheriting the deceased's property, as would have been the position of the deceased's children, if he had any. The statement of Verse 176, clearly supports this derivation.
Both these derivations can be made on the simple basis that in case of a childless person, if he has any brothers and/or sisters the share of the mother has been returned to what her share would have been if the deceased had any children.

[4] Regarding the share of the spouse, the Qur'an says:

You shall get half of what your wives leave, if they die childless. But if they do have children, your share shall then be a quarter of what they leave after carrying out any will made by the deceased or payment of any debt owed by her. And they (your wives) shall have a quarter of what you leave, if you die childless. But in case you have children, they shall then get one-eighth of what you leave

According to the referred part of the verse, in case a woman dies childless, the husband shall get half of her property and assets. While if she has any children, her husband's share shall be one-fourth. On the other hand, if a man dies, his wife shall get a quarter of his property and assets, if he dies childless, while she shall get one-eighth if he has any children.

[5] The share of the deceased's children has primarily been mentioned in the following words:

Allah enjoins you about [the share of inheritance of] your children: A male's share shall equal that of two females...

(For the purpose of understanding the verse more easily, its remaining part that relates to the share of a person's offspring -- i.e., in case there are only daughters, more than two shall have two-thirds of what has been left behind. And if there be only one daughter, her share shall be half -- is not yet being considered. This part of the verse shall be considered in detail, later.)

If the commandment of the Qur'an, regarding the law of inheritance had ended here, it would have meant that the total property and assets of the deceased are to be distributed among his/her children, according to the principle that each male child gets double the share of every female child. For example, if someone says: "This money is to be distributed among your children equally", it would simply imply that: 1) the money is to be distributed among all the children, according to the principle of equality; and 2) no one except the "children" has a right on the total money. In the same way, if someone says: "This money is to be distributed among your children in such a way that each female child gets half of what each male child gets", there shall be no change in the two stipulated implications of the sentence, except that in the latter case the principle of distribution, rather than "equality" shall be "each female gets half of what each male gets".

But, as a matter of fact, the commandment of the Qur'an does not end here. The Qur'an has mentioned a few other relations, like the parents and the spouse of the deceased, who are to be given a specified portion of the deceased's property. But the words used in describing the shares of the relations other than the children of the deceased are such that clearly imply that the other relations are to be given a fixed proportion of the total property and assets of the deceased, while his/her children are to share the balance of the property remaining after the share of the other relations has been given.

Suppose someone says: "Distribute this money equally among your children; give one-third of it to your parents". Obviously the implication of this sentence is quite clear. It simply means that first, one-third of the total money should be given to the parents and the remaining amount (two-thirds of the total) should be distributed equally among the children. In the same way, if someone says: "Distribute this money among your children in such a way that each girl gets half of what each boy gets; give one-third of it to your parents and a quarter of it to your wife", it would simply mean that after giving one-fourth of the money to the wife and one-third to the parents, the remaining five-twelfths is to be distributed among the children in such a way that each boy gets the double of what each girl gets. It also means that if the person does not have either or both the parents and the wife, the total money would then be distributed among his children according to the given principle.