74-79 if you wanna go for the 70s look. 80-87 if you like the 80s style.
There are so many different types of Corollas one is sure to fit your style: TE31, TE37, TE71, TE72, AE86.
The 2TC and 3TC engine have a pretty big following, so you can still get parts pretty easy for them, and of course the AE86 has it's own huge following.