what i have found, is that smaller, more local privately-owned insurance companies usually offer you the best rates as opposed to geico, progressive, state farm etc...

look in your local yellow pages under insurance companies, and call around to some local ones tomorrow. they will be able to give you a pretty accurate quote just by asking your DOB, how many, if any, tickets you have, what year/make/model your car is, if you're in school, etc.