Quote Originally Posted by JennB
I use the normal sites... Travelocity, Expedia, etc. when I rent cars.

I've been to NYC quite a few times and would never even think of renting a car there. The one time I drove my own car there, I parked it for the entire week.
Big mistake, do not drive your well kept car to NY. People there will destroy it if you park on the streets. They will back into your shit just to fit into a tiny space.