STAY AWAY FROM PROGRESSIVE!!! I used to work at a body shop and Progressive is among the Worst to deal with. i.e. paying for Correct repair, coming out to look at the car, and they try and cut coners by putting after market parts on. And when I say After market, I mean the Cheap shit.
This it (to me and those I worked with) the top 5 worst to deal with:
5. AllState
4. Progressive
3. Nationwide(not on your side)
2. Safeway( personal; exp.)
1. USAA. they are by FAR the worst insurance co. to deal with if you've been hit or even if you damaged your car all alone. I'll give U the guy's(insurance adjuster for Ga.) name if you run into them. And I'd be glad to give you som pointers should you find yourself involved with any of the above.

If it's not to expensive I would recommend

5. State Farm(I know the Ga. adjusters very well)
4. Acceptance(sounds cheap but decient people)
3. Hartford
2. Cincinatti(spelling) Casualit. Just send in the estimate/supplment and they'll pay it
1. Georgia Farm Bureau( same as #2) fantastic co.!