Okay.

So I just caught back up on this.

Guy shows a fake title to police and says he bought it one year ago, but you guys show the cop receipts still in the car?
You didn't call the insurance company to ask whos name the vehicle (with that vin #) was insured by?
You didn't call the bank to ask who the car loan (with that vin #) was insured by?
You just stood there and said this is bullshit?

Like, all this stuff would have been kind of good information to have, and if nothing else, puts some holes in his "purchased it a year ago" story.
It just seems like the amount of effort into "bringing justice" to this guy has been lackluster.