Quote Originally Posted by simontibbett View Post
If I bought a Miata for say $500 that's easily worth $1700 me trying to sell it for $1500 is perfectly fine.

In this case though that yellow Miata for $1800 was a joke.
Bingo. If you get a deal on it, you can sell it for what it's worth. If you get at for what it's worth, then you (in theory) shouldn't be able to sell it for more.