Does this piss you off?

[TheGodfather]

I'm going with fake as well.
'
The dog looked already dead. The yelping sounded too fake and not from the dog.

They did it just to make a sick joke, and I'm sure they knew everyone would think it was real. For those smart enough to know it's fake, it isn't that big of a deal.

[Frög]

if you saw the same video, with a old nasty Pig getting tossed, more than half of you would laugh.. wierd since pigs are smarter than dogs.. This video is very sad, but seriously..

I'm going with fake as well.
'
The dog looked already dead. The yelping sounded too fake and not from the dog.

They did it just to make a sick joke, and I'm sure they knew everyone would think it was real. For those smart enough to know it's fake, it isn't that big of a deal.

imo it didn't sound fake, my pup sounded exactly like that.. regardless i doubt anyone that has gone through puberty cannot imitate that noise.. so this knocks out all option except post editing..

i had my pup at about that age.. could barely open its eyes, he was abandoned and the only reason we found him was because of his yepping.. didn't even sound like a dog, but sounded just like the one on the vid..

your right, soldiers would'nt do that.. im sure he was dead.. just like the soldier in iraq a year or so ago who killed a whole family and raped the daughter that was 16 I think?

How can you say, for those "smart enough to know its fake"? this isn't "will the plane take off on a treadmill" which is proven, factual and science.. im sorry but this is probably the most ignorant and dumb comment in this thread.. Do you think the Marines, PETA etc... would do such an investigation if it was so obvious?

http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2008/...n3907067.shtml

With the quality of the video, its impossible for you or I to say.. I think its real, but I could be wrong, qnd so could the ppl who think it is fake.. i think im right, but im not going to affirm anything untill its fact.. thats the smart thing to do..


ANYWAY, this guy does not deserve death, and nobody would kill him because that would only put them in the same boat.. What he did was beyong wrong, but get real, its a fu.cking dog!! Do you know how many innocent people get killed weekly in iraq by soldiers? Do you know how many dogs get runned over and killed daily in the U.S? we are freaking out about this one dog when there are alot bigger issues to worry about..

And yes, i support the death penalty, but not for killing a dog..

It's ok for Vick to abuse dogs for years and fight them to death, but a couple of bored US soldiers who fight for our freedom are immediately scrutinized for tossing a dead puppy that they found.

UPDATE: Vick is in jail.. so i guess that makes it...... NOT ok.. and no one is sure wether the pup was dead or alive..

and if it was dead, its a pretty tasteless joke.. i might have to lol..