The IA Gallon Challenge

[Killer]

wait.... first person to drink it, then hold it down for an hour? or do we have an hour to drink it??? i'm confused by what paul said earlier...

[ironchef]

wait.... first person to drink it, then hold it down for an hour? or do we have an hour to drink it??? i'm confused by what paul said earlier...

You get up to an hour to drink it. Then after you're done drinking you have to hold it down for an hour.

[4dmin]

You get up to an hour to drink it. Then after you're done drinking you have to hold it down for an hour.

i was thinking first to drink it down and then hold it the longest... that would show some true skill and worth a ca$h prize

i have a feeling the results will be like this... 33% don't finish, 100% puke, 1 wins!!!

[Maniac1]

i was thinking first to drink it down and then hold it the longest... that would show some true skill and worth a ca$h prize

I agree. LOL but if you hold it for an hour shouldn't it start to get easier as the time passes?

[4dmin]

I agree. LOL but if you hold it for an hour shouldn't it start to get easier as the time passes?

thats what i was thinking...

[quickdodge®]

shouldn't it start to get easier as the time passes?

No sir. As milk settles, it gets heavier on your stomach. If you've eaten just before. It will weigh down on the food and, well............ If you haven't eaten in a while prior, then you're in for a surprise. Later, QD.

[Maniac1]

No sir. As milk settles, it gets heavier on your stomach. If you've eaten just before. It will weigh down on the food and, well............ If you haven't eaten in a while prior, then you're in for a surprise. Later, QD.

So I need a few snacks before I do it, got it.

[ironchef]

i was thinking first to drink it down and then hold it the longest... that would show some true skill and worth a ca$h prize

i have a feeling the results will be like this... 33% don't finish, 100% puke, 1 wins!!!

What if someone downs it first but someone else holds it down for longer.

[4dmin]

What if someone downs it first but someone else holds it down for longer.

well i would think it would go like this... first to get it down is first if in line for the cash... if he doesn't hold it down for 1 hour exactly it goes to who was 2nd, then 3rd, etc... it isn't all about who finishes first but who holds it down the longest + finish time. finishing just puts you in position for the ca$h holding it down makes a winner

[ironchef]

well i would think it would go like this... first to get it down is first if in line for the cash... if he doesn't hold it down for 1 hour exactly it goes to who was 2nd, then 3rd, etc... it isn't all about who finishes first but who holds it down the longest + finish time. finishing just puts you in position for the ca$h holding it down makes a winner

I'm going to have to echo Killer's statement. It would be a lot easier to declare a winner based on just who held it down the longest, and not having to worry about who finished downing it first etc.

[Maniac1]

I'm going to have to echo Killer's statement. It would be a lot easier to declare a winner based on just who held it down the longest, and not having to worry about who finished downing it first etc.

It comes to a few people doing it almost at the same time. There should be like a tiebreaker or something. Maybe have to drink another glass of milk?

[4dmin]

I'm going to have to echo Killer's statement. It would be a lot easier to declare a winner based on just who held it down the longest, and not having to worry about who finished downing it first etc.

doing it that way you could have multiple winners... the rules stated 1 hour to drink and 1 to wait... only way to determine clear winner in a 2 hour rule would be upon who finished first; that means they've held it down the longest

[quickdodge®]

well i would think it would go like this... first to get it down is first if in line for the cash... if he doesn't hold it down for 1 hour exactly it goes to who was 2nd, then 3rd, etc... it isn't all about who finishes first but who holds it down the longest + finish time. finishing just puts you in position for the ca$h holding it down makes a winner

But on the other hand, you have to have some sort of time limit. Anyone could take their time and drink the milk and it won't have the same effect as if you drank it a bit faster. I could probably drink a gallon in a couple of hours and not be fazed at all. I think an hour is a perfect time limit. Later, QD.

[4dmin]

But on the other hand, you have to have some sort of time limit. Anyone could take their time and drink the milk and it won't have the same effect as if you drank it a bit faster. I could probably drink a gallon in a couple of hours and not be fazed at all. I think an hour might still be too long to take to drink the milk. Later, QD.

now what i was suggesting is on top of the 2 hour time...

rules:

1) one hour to drink gallon of whole milk (can be done in 10 mins or 60 mins)
2) one hour to hold down the milk

with this way we could have multiple people hold it down for 1 hour... now if i'm throwing down ca$h i want my moneys worth... say we start at 7-8pm for drinking 8-9pm to hold it down; if clock starts per contestant once they finish drinking you could potentially hold down for more then an hour which would declare you the overall winner.

example:

guy #1 starts at 7pm finishes at 730pm but holds til 9pm(endtime) he has a total of 90 mins

guy #2 starts at 7pm finishes at 8pm but holds til 9pm(endtime) he has total of 60 mins

[Killer]

i was thinking first to drink it down and then hold it the longest... that would show some true skill and worth a ca$h prize

i have a feeling the results will be like this... 33% don't finish, 100% puke, 1 wins!!!

i think that may get too confusing... cause what if some one drinks it in like ten minutes... then we all have to wait and see if they puke or not in an hour... i think it'll be hard to track who drank it quickest yet held it longest....

[4dmin]

i think that may get too confusing... cause what if some one drinks it in like ten minutes... then we all have to wait and see if they puke or not in an hour... i think it'll be hard to track who drank it quickest yet held it longest....

wouldnt' be too hard to track... the person holding the ca$h writes down the drank time and starts a watch.

[Maniac1]

wouldnt' be too hard to track... the person holding the ca$h writes down the drank time and starts a watch.

Sounds good to me.

[jayjaySTI]

im down

[quickdodge®]

im down

How sweet. We may finally meet. Later, QD.

[jayjaySTI]

How sweet. We may finally meet. Later, QD.

ohhhhhhhh yeah and maybe we can have a one to one contest so bring one more gallon