Went to Sprayglo at 1826 Metropolitan Parkway Southwest today. The guy I talked to said no one named Gabe works there. They quoted me approx $450 which would include pulling out the fender and repainting it. Then I went over to World Toyota Collision Center and they quoted me around $1100 because they wanted to buy a new turn signal, new fender, new fender flare, etc. Both places would need to keep the car for 3 days to get the job done.

So, I decided I'm just going to duck tape the turn signal back in and have my own paint guy fix it when I go back to FL in a week or two. His price will probably fall somewhere in between the two quotes I got today but at least I know his work is good. I've had him paint a few of my cars including the Quicksilver Supra. Plus I won't need to get a rental car back home for the three days while it's in the shop, so that should save me some hassle.