sounds like wheel bearings, and or 2 different axles that you have! and iono if your axles are newnew or reman, but mostly all re manufactured axles, come as is. You cant really tell if they in good condition or not. The appearance of the axles may look good, but it's teh bearings inside of the axles it self! i've went through plenty of reman axles and decided to just get brand new ones!! ...