Quote Originally Posted by ATL86 View Post
Just watched the latest episode on Hulu. It basically went with my theory that they are all dead in purgatory (island), the man in black is the imprisoned devil and Jacob is a prison guard angel. Great episode and the guy who plays Richard Alpert is a good actor.
this is not what happened, grrr. They were not dead on the island. They all died at different times, different places. When Jack goes inside the church and meets his father, his father tells him, we are all dead, we have all been waiting for you(something along those lines). And he than says, we all died at different times. Some of us died before u, some of us died after you. Some of them died at the island, some died after they left the island and so forth. The Island was real, everything was real(well the reality of the show or w.e.)