Quote Originally Posted by bodhi View Post
i thought it was dumb. it seemed really cool and very suspenseful for a while, but when you find out that the whole thing was actually him being crazy it just felt really weak.

that's such a cheap plot device.
they set up this whole movie with all these scenes including him traveling to get to the island on a ferry, and it turns out that the whole thing never happened, and that nothing we saw that set up the whole movie ever took place. that's just fucking silly.

you can't have a movie that shows you watching the main character and then you find out nothing that you watched ever really took place - that's retarded.
yeah those scenes happened. Remember they let him act out his fantasy so maybe he might cure himself.