Originally Posted by
drpepper14
I liked the movie, but obviously unhappy with its comparison to the book.
No battle @ Hogwarts/around Hagrid's hut
No Dumbledore funeral
No Dumbledore trying to persuade draco to go into hiding and telling him that Voldemort probably expects him to die
Ginny didn't hide the potions book, Harry does in the book which leads to him finding the tiara horcrux in the 7th book
No mention of Grindewald
No explanation of the connected chests in diagon alley and the room of requirement (or at least how the one got into hogwarts)
No intro or explanation of Fenrir Grayback
Tonks rescues harry (not luna) on the train after draco petrifies him, breaks his nose, and leaves him under his cloak
Harry is not paralyzed under his cloak by dumbledore before he is killed (to keep him from interfering I presumed)
The scene with the weasley house burning down is not supposed to happen, so I guess it will be rebuilt in the 7th because a lot of the book takes place there
Lupin and Tonks are not open about their relationship yet (they are holding hands in the 6th movie)
NO VOLDEMORT??????
No meeting with the muggle prime minister which I think needs to be shown instead of just mentioning in the 5th movie that he has been warned
No talk of lucius in Azkaban
George losing an ear in the hogwarts battle
I could go on, but it's been a year since I read the 6th book which I have now started again lol
Scenes that better be in the 7th/8th movie
- The meeting at the Malfoys with voldemort and all of the death eaters
- Everyone being held hostage and escaping from the malfoys
- The multiple harry potter scene when they must escape the dursleys and a bunch of people are killed
- The break in at Gringotts
- The EPIC battle scene at hogwarts that should take up like 30 min of the movie AT LEAST
- Harry watching Nagini kill snape and then finding out his true loyalties
- A lot of scenes of Harry, Hermione, and Ron in hiding and on the run
- Voldemort flying without a broom across europe hunting down the elder wand (I thought it was awesome because it something pretty much no one can do)
- Mention of the elder wand and how it changes hands (This is ultimately why voldemort dies, he tries to kill harry with it twice when in fact harry is the true master of it @ the time)
- Visits to Harry's childhood home and the town in which dumbledore grew up
- The book about dumbledore and his sortid past with his family and being an elitist pure blood
- Break in @ the ministry of magic
- Snape running hogwarts acting like a death eater and constantly outcasting friends of harry's
- The deaths of one of the weasley twins, lupin, tonks, mad eye moody, and hedwig
- The final scene with harry married to ginny, hermione and ron married, and running into an older draco when they are all sending their kids off to their first year @ hogwarts
Im sure there are more i'd like to see, but I probably won't even see all of these
I can't wait for the 7th/8th movies to come out though, hopefully with at least 5 hours of screen time they can make up for all of the important missed info they left out in 6 which leads to a ton of stuff in the 7th book. Without it, the 7th book/movie makes no sense.
Reply With Quote