I'm not going to vote on this because I don't feel really strongly either way. I'm not a matching numbers kind of guy, but at the same time I like muscle cars that look pretty original. For instance, I would definitely take the first Camaro you posted over the second. Personally, I think a new set of wheels (no bigger than 16 inches, maybe 17) and maybe a little drop (none of this slammed import, I need to alter my daily commute so I don't hit any speed bumps, trend) makes for the perfect looking muscle car.