well seeing that you drive a truck, do you intend on keeping a truck as a daily driver? if not, you can't go wrong with corollas, or camrys. really nice and reliable, if you dont mind the non sporty look.
if you want to keep a truck, get a new tacoma, or a frontier. very nice trucks. good gas mileage for a small pickup.
but if i were to pick one from your poll choices, def the jetta gli. i always had love for those. they look really nice and sporty and you still get the 4 door grocery getter factor out of it. im not sure how they do in mpg but i think they are pretty good.
did you have an evo? or a eclipse? or still have it