I would go with the honda. They're incredibly screwed together, and they're pretty sorted right out the box. The suspension, motor, and the overall feel are just great if you get a good one. Plus they rev to the sky and back. Also, parts are RIDICULOUSLY available.
Aside from that, I've seen some pretty decent power out of that generation of eclipse. I met a guy recently driving one in flat primer grey pushing about 300whp. I was impressed. He had the AWD model though.