STI or EVO

[mengus200sx]

A new year is coming around the corner and everyones want a new car. Well i happened to be one of those people... I was thinkin for gettin a 05 up STI because i love how it handle and turns. I test drive 3 STI already and love it, but then i test drive the EVo 8 and I love it too, but then i don't know which to chose...it like doing rock, paper, scissors shoot!!! YOU know wat i mean!!

I was thinkin if everyone or the owner of the STi and EVO can give me a little detail of how the car handle or ride and why u chose that car,

Thanx for ur times

[tko]

u will get some replys tomorrow

[yerrow]

big horsepower, better seats, quicker steering...EVO
personality, better interior, not based off a lancer, STi

[Big Baller]

What are you going to do with it?

[patrick4588]

What are you going to do with it?

x2

[WHT_EP3]

raw stupid horse power the easy way.-EVO
you want looks with a lil pep in the step.-STI
i never owned neither but i been told it is like that

[EM1toEVO]

Honestly you can't go wrong with either car. Great bang for the buck. Both cars WILL be very reliable IF you take care of it. I have an Evo, but it was a toss up since I loved and drove both cars before making my decision. In the end there were several factors that pushed me to the Evo. Looks, big power for cheaper, way better "feel" while driving(to me anyway). Also, I really preferred the 5 speed gearbox(non MR) as opposed to a 6 speed only in the STI. You feel like you are rowing a boat with such short gear ratios. Like everyone said above, it all depeends on what you want out of it. Remember that both cars are built for performance and sacrifice some amenities to focus on giving you the most bang for the buck in performance. There are other cars with better fit and finish, but that doesn't matter to me as much.

[BKgen®]

NEITHER.... they're overpopulated as it is. Be original... because until you get the money to mod it, you'll be just another stock evo or sti on the street.


p.s.- don't get a tiburon lols

[WHT_EP3]

or a pontiac GTO, not many ppl like them but they are hella fast with no effort
headers intake exhaust and you will pull 11's-10's down a track <--- exaggeration-maybe

[EM1toEVO]

NEITHER.... they're overpopulated as it is. Be original... because until you get the money to mod it, you'll be just another stock evo or sti on the street.


p.s.- don't get a tiburon lols

I hardly see any Evos around Athens.

[BKgen®]

I hardly see any Evos around Athens.

i'm saying just in general.

however, i wouldn't mind seeing someone go out on a limb and buy one of the new Evo X's. granted, both the new evo and sti are both butt-f*cking-ugly, i think the evo is the lesser of two evils... while the sti seems to get progressively uglier and uglier every year. subaru's design team should seriously wake the hell up.

[JITB]

neither they turn u into bad people

[EM1toEVO]

neither they turn u into bad people

.........................

[The_ CaneCorso]

Whats a car..........j/k

[mengus200sx]

true ..i live in winder and i don't see too much evo, sti or a si hatchback around town, only my si.. i think ...well A BIG THANKS to everyone who help me out with there details and all..i wish i can rep u guys but i don't know how to, or

and to the question (wat r u going to do with it?)...well it just going to be my dd ..back and forth .....but more power..bc i still love power

I hardly see any Evos around Athens.

[WickedIXMR]

If you plan on staying just bolt ons and very mild mods. Id say go with the sti. The sti has more driver comfort. Like it has a six cd changer, CRUISE CONTROL, climate control. Just some things that you would probably like in the future. But if you plan on working on your own car all the time, plan on making some good power, I'd get an evo. Working on an evo is like working on a honda. Evos can make 400whp on stock turbo just bolt ons. And make 500whp on stock block and even stock ecu. Both are really personal preferance and those are my person preferances.

[DUBSf22c]

If you plan on staying just bolt ons and very mild mods. Id say go with the sti. The sti has more driver comfort. Like it has a six cd changer, CRUISE CONTROL, climate control. Just some things that you would probably like in the future. But if you plan on working on your own car all the time, plan on making some good power, I'd get an evo. Working on an evo is like working on a honda. Evos can make 400whp on stock turbo just bolt ons. And make 500whp on stock block and even stock ecu. Both are really personal preferance and those are my person preferances.

Very good point.

Honestly b/c of insurance cost I went with a STi.
(80+ more a month for the evo)

I plan on the a full cosworth engine and a 35r kit but for now its way more comfort then evo would be going back and forth to work and the interior is better IMO... but seats on those evo are nioce.. Suby is safer!
(too bad we dont get seat choices like europe and japan)

I have driven willumpb14's evo from stock to the beast its growing to be..So i have a decent amount of knowledge of both cars

[WickedIXMR]

Very good point.

Honestly b/c of insurance cost I went with a STi.
(80+ more a month for the evo)

I plan on the a full cosworth engine and a 35r kit but for now its way more comfort then evo would be going back and forth to work and the interior is better IMO... but seats on those evo are nioce.. Suby is safer!
(too bad we dont get seat choices like europe and japan)

I have driven willumpb14's evo from stock to the beast its growing to be..So i have a decent amount of knowledge of both cars

Thats wierd lightspeed on here had an sti and now has an evo and said his insurance is cheaper with the evo.

[Tuan]

If your going to track the car a lot get a EVO. If you spend a lot of time in the car but on drive around town then get the STI

[WickedIXMR]

If your going to track the car a lot get a EVO. If you spend a lot of time in the car but on drive around town then get the STI

What he said..

[black]

Just like WickedIXMR said, everyone has diffrent taste in cars. With bolt on's, on both cars. They would be making around the same wheel horsepower, if you're looking for the fastest of the two. Go with the Evo, both cars look real nice tho, I personally like the 06+ STi over an Evo.

[tru2nrtt777]

or a pontiac GTO, not many ppl like them but they are hella fast with no effort
headers intake exhaust and you will pull 11's-10's down a track <--- exaggeration-maybe

Just a slight exageration, stock can run low 13's. With CAI/H/DP/HFC/CB it can run uber low 12's(12.1's).Gut the interior a bit and you can hit high 11's but you are gonna burn a few gallons of fuel each run.

Trust me, I know Chevy.

[jayjaySTI]

if u want something easy to work with go with the evo my sti is a ***** to work on but the looks are better specialy on the 04 and 05s in my opinion both cars have handle great is up to u ...

[jayjaySTI]

Just like WickedIXMR said, everyone has diffrent taste in cars. With bolt on's, on both cars. They would be making around the same wheel horsepower, if you're looking for the fastest of the two. Go with the Evo, both cars look real nice tho, I personally like the 06+ STi over an Evo.

hell ****ing no with the same bolt ons they dont make the same power wtf evos respond better to the mods plus when u mod and sti u have to get tune or u will be runing rich as **** and hiting fuel cuts all day

[black]

hell ****ing no with the same bolt ons they dont make the same power wtf evos respond better to the mods plus when u mod and sti u have to get tune or u will be runing rich as **** and hiting fuel cuts all day

Let me put it this way since you don't seem to know much about these two cars. An Evo with a TBE/I/Flash should put down around 300whp. Same for the STi, with a TBE/I/Flash, it too should put down around 300whp. Of course the Impreza will put down more torque due to it's extra half liter. Still, the Evo comes with a slitly bigger turbo from factory, so of course it will boost more psi and have slitly better topend. So it makes up for it.

In the end, if you want to compare the two in a straight line race or test. It will come down to who is the better driver.
ps; I would go with an STi, I just love that boxer exhaust tone.

[Tuan]

Let me put it this way since you don't seem to know much about these two cars. An Evo with a TBE/I/Flash should put down around 300whp. Same for the STi, with a TBE/I/Flash, it too should put down around 300whp. Of course the Impreza will put down more torque due to it's extra half liter. Still, the Evo comes with a slitly bigger turbo from factory, so of course it will boost more psi and have slitly better topend. So it makes up for it.

In the end, if you want to compare the two in a straight line race or test. It will come down to who is the better driver.
ps; I would go with an STi, I just love that boxer exhaust tone.

Ummm the turbo on the STI will run out of breath at around 6k rpm and the evo will pull

[black]

Ummm the turbo on the STI will run out of breath at around 6k rpm and the evo will pull

What are you talking about? I said nothing about the STi pulling hard til redline, of course the Evo pulls up top. After reading your post again, I still don't see what you were trying to prove.

[Tuan]

yo calm down angry child. You said in a straight line it comes down to the driver. I've seen a ton of stock sti getting waxed by stock evo on the HWY and strip. The sti may have more TQ but the turbo sucks after 6k. Also unless you have a 07 the gearing sucks on the strip bc you have to shift to 5th b4 u cross the line where the evo doesn't.

[jayjaySTI]

yo calm down angry child. You said in a straight line it comes down to the driver. I've seen a ton of stock sti getting waxed by stock evo on the HWY and strip. The sti may have more TQ but the turbo sucks after 6k. Also unless you have a 07 the gearing sucks on the strip bc you have to shift to 5th b4 u cross the line where the evo doesn't.

yep gears suck, is more fun do

[black]

yo calm down angry child. You said in a straight line it comes down to the driver. I've seen a ton of stock sti getting waxed by stock evo on the HWY and strip. The sti may have more TQ but the turbo sucks after 6k. Also unless you have a 07 the gearing sucks on the strip bc you have to shift to 5th b4 u cross the line where the evo doesn't.

You must have seen some newbie driving the STi, cuase I have seen Evo's pulling STi's and STi's pulling Evos. Just cause the turbo gives out around 6k doesn't mean you can't keep going all the way to 7500rpm. No lift shifting also helps, you hold boost while shifts and keep pulling. It all comes down to the driver, like I said already twice.

And im far from a child.

[jayjaySTI]

You must have seen some newbie driving the STi, cuase I have seen Evo's pulling STi's and STi's pulling Evos. Just cause the turbo gives out around 6k doesn't mean you can't keep going all the way to 7500rpm. No lift shifting also helps, you hold boost while shifts and keep pulling. It all comes down to the driver, like I said already twice.

And im far from a child.

yeah no offense to any sti driver but i seen really bad ones, and plis stop babying the **** out of ur stis

[Tuan]

Another point for the person that started this thread, if your going to work on this car yourself the get a evo. The sti is a pain in the ass to work on. Ex: changing spark plugs

[jayjaySTI]

Another point for the person that started this thread, if your going to work on this car yourself the get a evo. The sti is a pain in the ass to work on. Ex: changing spark plugs

yep

[jayjaySTI]

get the STI and thats it

[Twinturbo6]

Get a Mazdaspeed 6...

[OneSlow5pt0]

get a celica GT4...........but id go with STI,i just like thier looks more

[Big Baller]

1. 90% of the people in this thread don't know what they are talking about.

2. The STI is not hard to work on.

3. The STI and the EVO on track in stock form lap within a .10 seconds of each other.

4. The STI is a better track car, I put over 10,000 track miles on a stock motor making 470whp.

5. The Transmission in the STI is way better.

6. The EVO feels cheap

7. The steering on the EVO is much nicer.

8. The EVO has an Oil cooler

9. You need to buy an Oil cooler for an STI.

10. They are both awesome cars, I've had both on track on multiple occasions as far as stock performance goes they are very close. Modified I would rather have the STI.

11. This is the Big One....If its going to be you're daily driver the STI is flat out a better car.

Good Luck Matt

[jayjaySTI]

FOCK this thread it all goes down to personal opinion, for get about the thread and get the STI is pure sex

[mengus200sx]

yea THANKS AGAIN ....after fixing up my si ...i going for a STI..c how it is...bc i really like it....

[EM1toEVO]

1. 90% of the people in this thread don't know what they are talking about.

2. The STI is not hard to work on.

3. The STI and the EVO on track in stock form lap within a .10 seconds of each other.

4. The STI is a better track car, I put over 10,000 track miles on a stock motor making 470whp.

5. The Transmission in the STI is way better.

6. The EVO feels cheap

7. The steering on the EVO is much nicer.

8. The EVO has an Oil cooler

9. You need to buy an Oil cooler for an STI.

10. They are both awesome cars, I've had both on track on multiple occasions as far as stock performance goes they are very close. Modified I would rather have the STI.

11. This is the Big One....If its going to be you're daily driver the STI is flat out a better car.

Good Luck Matt

You sir, are a wise man!