everything is a starter car. U need to weigh your options. FWD vs RWD, 4cyl vs 6cyl, how much parts are going to be for each car. How much power am i looking for with stock or built motor. Which is the cheapest, most reliable. This decision is up to you.
try to find friends with each car, who has the most problems, see if u can test drive them, get a feel for the cars, etc...
good luck man!
PS-i nominate any Honda/Acura. both have different look appeals but the teggy is a little faster to begin with (i think).