Really, there's no way to know unless he's got passes on slicks & street tires to compare. Some setups hook better on street tires than others. Some drivers can't extract the full potential of their slicks. Does he have slips to compare streets vs. slicks?
Sometimes the outcome is surprising. Once, I ran my car on 225/50/15 tires at the track and ran slower than I did on my 195/60/15 tires. The 225 tires were a stickier compound, wider, on lighter wheels, etc. So why did I run slower? The rules of thumb aren't absolutes. The only way to ever KNOW something is to have done it for yourself.
Well it certainly requires more grease under your fingernails than popping down 40-50 large at the dealership.![]()