
Originally Posted by
Elrichthain
When FDR established welfare it was necessary for the times, and it helped fuel the economy and get us out of a depression. It was a wonderful thing. However, he established it as a temporary fix. I believe it still does a very good job in our society, but it definitely needs to be reformed, I will completely agree with that. Taking it away? No. I have it tends to HELP our economy more than hurt it. Yes, it does hurt the upper-middle to the upper classes, because they get (unfairly) taxed higher. However, I live with a woman who has two kids, and after her work went out of business unexpectedly, the compensation you so unwillingly delt helped her keep her kids. She did get back on her feet, and she's now managing a job in a Barnes & Noble cafe, and she hates the job, but she does it for her kids...to give them a chance she never had. She doesn't receive the help anymore, but without it would be without her two girls, and probably severly lack motivation.
The question is would you rather cancel the program because so many people abuse it and even breed people into a shitty life, and in so doing keeping people like my roommate unable to keep her kids, or would you rather help her out and give her kids a good life because she's TRYING, but in the meantime happen to encourage someone to take advantage. It NEEDS to be reformed, but it'd be too difficult to set a standard, or even make sure people meet the standards. I pray we find a good way to do so, it would save tons of money, but I would rather not cancel it completely in the meantime.
I agree with you about the gun thing. I think the laws can get ridiculuos, but should we have no way to control who gets a gun and who doesn't? You go to the extreme of insinuating we should have NO restrictions on buying guns. We need restrictions, for very obvious reasons. By the way, the Second Amendment, in context, is we have a right to bear arms for local militia, to preserve out natural rights. Tell me how many local militias you've come into contact with post-industrial revolution. I think we have the right to defend ourselves and our families--wouldn't deny anybody that right--but wouldn't you say we've kind of twisted the meaning of the Amendment?
By the way, we're always going to have guns: it's like drugs. There are too many people that will fight to keep it alive, so no democrat could be stupid enough to fight to elimiate guns in this country, just try to make sure it's going to the right people. So don't worry, you'll be able to keep your guns no matter who's running this country.
I'm not going to fight the gay marriage (because I've found it resides largely on your moral system, i.e. religion, and I take it your a hard core southern baptist based on the heat of your argument for being republican) except to say this: "marriage" is a religious institute, and should be determined by the religion of the person wanting to marry. What's being faught, essentially, are the privileges of a gay man or woman when being recognized by the government as "married" based on their institution of marriage. With that being the case, I believe the government SHOULD allow gay marriage, because it's not in their right (imo) to determine who is more worthy of marrying.
My last little is about your "if you don't like it, get out" attitude. This is a wonderful country, and we have a lot of great rights. However, we also have responsibilities, including fighting for our rights, as we feel we have. Believe me, if all the democrats left the country, you'd be miserable. You'd have nothing to fight, and more than likely our country would turn into a dictatorship or owned by corporations. Guess how many rights you'll have left then? As many that keeps them on top. So I'm sick of people saying "if you don't like it, leave." If we abolished guns, allowed gays to marry, and taxed the rich 70% or more of their earnings to help the homeless, would you move? Or would you fight to abolish it? We run on a pendulum, we go to extreme left and right, and we're sitting on extreme right. Don't get too upset or anything, but we're about to start swinging left, I could almost guarantee you.