Which do you think 'works' better

[DinanM3atl]

I keep coming back to this photo. The overall colors of the walls, the vehicle and lighting screams B/W while not being black and white. The track nature of the vehicles screams selective color in my mind on the racing harness...

Is B/W with very minor selective color work better than than the photo edit? The ONLY change is B/W and selective color.


Selective Colver with B/W:
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3258/3109392358_92cbd29d94_b.jpg


Standard Edit:
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3063/3109391276_8d6b8898c2_b.jpg

[TonyRSX]

number 1

[Sport1.3]

i like the 2nd better :dunno: the 1st is too dark

[james]

as much as i hate the "color selection" fad, i think number one works tons better.

[Mr. Clean]

numba one fosho. the little bit of color from the concrete isn't worth drawing the eye from the car.

[amandDA]

#1 is always better...

[Mr. Clean]

lulz ^

[boostedb16]

i like them both.

[Arm&hammer]

number one is much better!

[Alan®]

problem is that both shots are so similar that selective color or not its hard to tell the difference. with that said standard edit is my choice

[imbosile]

as much as i hate the "color selection" fad, i think number one works tons better.


I agree, maybe try one completely black and white?

[.blank cd]

#1

[EJ_Allmota]

Numero UNO!!

[Random Hero]

Juan.

[DinanM3atl]

Well that is what I was leaning towards ;)